AOPA: NTSB Not The Law On Service Bulletins | Aero-News Network
Aero-News Network
RSS icon RSS feed
podcast icon MP3 podcast
Subscribe Aero-News e-mail Newsletter Subscribe

Airborne Unlimited -- Most Recent Daily Episodes

Episode Date

Airborne-Monday

Airborne-Tuesday

Airborne-Wednesday Airborne-Thursday

Airborne-Friday

Airborne On YouTube

Airborne-Unlimited-06.02.25

Airborne-NextGen-06.03.25

AirborneUnlimited-06.04.25

Airborne-AffordableFlyers-06.05.25

AirborneUnlimited-06.06.25

Sun, Jul 02, 2006

AOPA: NTSB Not The Law On Service Bulletins

AOPA says the that service bulletins aren't mandatory for Part 91 aircraft owners, regardless of what the NTSB says. And now AOPA is asking the FAA to remain firm in upholding that longstanding policy and interpretation of the law.

"The FAA's past and present opinion is that while service bulletins and instructions are not mandatory, they may be used by mechanics as an acceptable method, but not the only method, to show compliance with the regulations when performing maintenance, alterations, or preventive maintenance," AOPA Executive Vice President of Government Affairs Andy Cebula said in a letter to Nicholas A. Sabatini, the FAA's associate administrator for aviation safety.

"Should the FAA deem it necessary to issue a letter of interpretation in the interest of clarity and to avoid misapplication of existing regulations, the agency must reaffirm that service bulletins and service instructions are not mandatory for general aviation.... A manufacturer is not allowed to unilaterally require compliance with future service bulletins or instructions," said Cebula.

The issue was raised by the NTSB's ruling in the case of Administrator v. Law, in which a mechanic was accused of performing unairworthy repairs. In essence, the FAA claimed the mechanic used procedures not approved by the administrator.

But the NTSB took it a step farther, saying that "by not using the manufacturer's prescribed inspection technique, [the] respondent violated the regulations...."

That language would seem to require compliance with service bulletins or service instructions, known and yet to be issued, when referenced by the manufacturer's maintenance manual.

For general aviation aircraft certificated under CAR 3 (the majority of GA aircraft, designed before 1972), that's not the law. Any mandatory changes, repairs, or upgrades to an aircraft must be FAA approved and must go through the rulemaking process, including public comment, as required by the Administrative Procedures Act.

(For newer aircraft certificated under Part 23, service bulletins can be made mandatory if approved by the FAA and incorporated into the airworthiness limitations section of the aircraft's maintenance manual or instructions for continued airworthiness. Also, service bulletins are usually mandatory for aircraft flying in commercial service.)

In the case of Administrator v. Law, the FAA filed an appeal brief clearly stating that the mechanic was not in violation of the regulations for failing to follow the manufacturer's service bulletins, but rather for failing to use acceptable practices. "Why NTSB failed to mirror the FAA's language in their decision is a mystery," Cebula said.

AOPA told the FAA that the association was "concerned that the language used by the NTSB in their decision is contrary to established policy, practice, and law, and that mechanics and possibly FAA inspectors could misinterpret the NTSB's decision to require compliance with all manufacturers' service bulletins and instructions."

As FAA rulings have made clear through the years, following acceptable procedures does not necessarily mean mandatory adherence to service bulletins unapproved by the FAA.

FMI: www.ntsb.gov

Advertisement

More News

ANN's Daily Aero-Term (06.03.25): No Gyro Approach

No Gyro Approach A radar approach/vector provided in case of a malfunctioning gyro-compass or directional gyro. Instead of providing the pilot with headings to be flown, the contro>[...]

ANN's Daily Aero-Linx (06.03.25)

Aero Linx: European Hang Gliding and Paragliding Union (EHPU) The general aim of the EHPU is to promote and protect hang gliding and paragliding in Europe. In order to achieve this>[...]

ANN FAQ: Turn On Post Notifications

Make Sure You NEVER Miss A New Story From Aero-News Network Do you ever feel like you never see posts from a certain person or page on Facebook or Instagram? Here’s how you c>[...]

Airborne 05.30.25: Anti-Helicopter Bill, PW Strike Done, All-Electric Bristell

Also: Duffy Wants $$$, KS Airports, Morningside U’s Aviation School, New Airstrip In ID After 6 were killed in a helicopter crash over the Hudson River, several US Representa>[...]

Airborne 05.29.25: ATC Bonu$, VX4 eVTOL Flies, Starship 9 Test

Also: Hermeus Quarterhorse MK1, Seaplane Rating Guide, Vietjet A330neos, SFO Wacky Weed Bust As the air traffic controller shortage trudges on, the US Department of Transportation >[...]

blog comments powered by Disqus



Advertisement

Advertisement

Podcasts

Advertisement

© 2007 - 2025 Web Development & Design by Pauli Systems, LC