U.S. Judge Awards BOC Aviation $406-Million | Aero-News Network
Aero-News Network
RSS icon RSS feed
podcast icon MP3 podcast
Subscribe Aero-News e-mail Newsletter Subscribe

Airborne Unlimited -- Most Recent Daily Episodes

Episode Date



Airborne-Wednesday Airborne-Thursday


Airborne On YouTube



Airborne-Unlimited-05.15.24 Airborne-AffordableFlyers-05.16.24


Thu, Apr 13, 2023

U.S. Judge Awards BOC Aviation $406-Million

Ruling Addresses Trio of 747-8s Stuck in Russia

On Tuesday, 11 April 2023, a U.S. judge ordered AirBridgeCargo Airlines LLC—Russia’s largest cargo air-carrier—and its parent company, Volga-Dnepr Logistics BV to pay aircraft lessor BOC Aviation Ltd. $406-million after the former were declared in default on the leases of three Boeing 747-8 freighters.

Following a one-day non-jury trial, U.S. District Judge Lewis Liman found in favor of BOC Aviation despite the defendant companies’ inability to operate the leased 747s following Russia’s February 2022 move against Ukraine and subsequent international sanctions which prohibited Western aircraft OEMs and lessors from delivering aircraft, aircraft parts, or aircraft technical support to Russian airlines and private owners of Western aircraft.

Lawyers for AirBridgeCargo Airlines LLC and Volga-Dnepr Logistics BV have yet to comment on the ruling.

Aircraft lessors have sued multiple insurers and lessees, primarily in European courts, for billions of dollars over hundreds of Western aircraft mired in Russia since the commencement of the Russo-Ukrainian conflict.

BOC Aviation alleged AirBridgeCargo went into default subsequent to its inability to maintain required reinsurance coverage. The company set forth it has thus far recovered one of the leased 747-8s and two of its four engines. The remaining engines and the two additional 747 freighters remain in Russia, however.

BOC Aviation’s majority shareholder is Bank of China Ltd.

In his 57-page decision, Judge Liman ruled BOC Aviation had proved the Russian government had “effected a seizure” of the disputed aircraft and engines by purposefully precluding their use outside Russia, “save, perhaps, to areas in Ukraine of for the purposes of the war.”

The judge opined that AirBridgeCargo Airlines’ willful operation of the trio of 747-8s strictly within the borders Russia and Ukraine had undermined BOC Aviation’s ability to carry out its right to reclaim possession of subject aircraft.

Liman rejected AirBridgeCargo's defense which contended neither side could have foreseen a default and cited the impossibility of grounding the 747-8s outside Russia insomuch as Moscow had specifically ordered them returned to Russian soil.

Similar arguments have been made in other cases, but a prevailing lack of standardized terms and the jet industry’s tradition of contractual secrecy have hampered aircraft lessors’ attempts to pool their claims into a singular class action suit.

Parties interested in reading further on the BOC Aviation Ltd vs AirBridgeCargo Airlines case should reference: BOC Aviation Ltd vs AirBridgeCargo Airlines LLC et al, U.S. District Court, Southern District of New York, No. 22-02070.

FMI: www.airbridgecargo.com


More News

ANN's Daily Aero-Term (05.21.24): ACCAS

ACCAS (usually pronounced ACK-kis) - AltoCumulus CAStellanus; mid-level clouds (bases generally 8 to 15 thousand feet), of which at least a fraction of their upper parts show cumul>[...]

ANN's Daily Aero-Linx (05.21.24)

Aero Linx: KC-46A Pegasus The KC-46A is the first phase in recapitalizing the U.S. Air Force's aging tanker fleet. With greater refueling, cargo and aeromedical evacuation capabili>[...]

Airborne Affordable Flyers 05.16.24: PRA Runway, Wag-Aero Sold, Young Eagles

Also: Paramotor Champ's, Electric Ultralight, ICON BK Update, Burt Rutan at Oshkosh! The Popular Rotorcraft Association is reaching out for help in rebuilding their private runway >[...]

Airborne 05.22.24: NS-25 Chute Failure, #HonorTheWASP, SkyCourier 'Combi'

Also: VAI v Anti-Heli Actions, Electric Aircraft Symposium, 2024 FAA Drone/AAM Symposium, Gravitymaster Blue Origin's seventh passenger flight ended with a smidgeon of drama when o>[...]

Airborne 05.15.24: Ghost Sq MidAir, B-2 Junked, Dream Chaser Readies

Also: Flt School Security, G600 Steep-Approach, Honduran Aid, PW545D Cert Two aircraft performing at the Fort Lauderdale Air Show clipped wings during a routine last Sunday, spooki>[...]

blog comments powered by Disqus





© 2007 - 2024 Web Development & Design by Pauli Systems, LC