Buzz Off! Industry Fights FlightPrep Patent Offensive | Aero-News Network
Aero-News Network
RSS icon RSS feed
podcast icon MP3 podcast
Subscribe Aero-News e-mail Newsletter Subscribe

Airborne Unlimited -- Most Recent Daily Episodes

Episode Date



Airborne-Wednesday Airborne-Thursday


Airborne On YouTube




Airborne-Flt Training-05.26.22

Airborne Unlimited-05.27.22

Thu, Dec 16, 2010

Buzz Off! Industry Fights FlightPrep Patent Offensive

FlightPrep Seems To Losing The Battle For The Hearts, Minds And Wallets Of The Online Flight Planning Biz...

ANN continues to receive reports of an aggressive effort by FlightPrep (a company owned by Stenbock & Everson) to seek compensation from a number of online businesses that offer some manner of flight planning utility or services... and by and large, this effort is falling on deaf ears.

While FlightPrep apparently scared into shuttering its sight after filing a lawsuit claiming over $3 million a month in damages, (and another that reportedly hadn't even gotten a letter from FlightPrep yet), and reaching an agreement with (who reportedly made the deal, which they are not allowed to discuss, based on the anticipated costs of fighting the patent), FlightPrep seems to be waging a losing battle. Industry reaction has been sharply negative while a number of sources indicate that the FlightPrep patent is seen to be "broad and over-reaching."

Further; a number of examples of online flight planning utilities have been cited as IP created prior to the earliest initiation of a patent application by FlightPrep's Stenbock & Everson.

Both industry giant Jeppesen and their client AOPA (which has a 'me-too' flight planning utility built by Jepp) have denied FlightPrep's attempts to seek compensation... simply by deciding that their operations do NOT infringe on the controversial FlightPrep patent and thereafter refusing FlightPrep's attempts to contact them.

ANN has learned that has also taken the path of refusal in that they reportedly believe that the FlightPrep patent has no bearing on their offerings and has refused to offer to compensate an increasingly frustrated FlightPrep.

The latest refusals comes from FlightAware who states that they have "received many calls & emails from concerned FlightAware users wanting to know how the recent FlightPrep patent news affects us.

We normally would not comment on this kind of matter, but we have decided to provide some insight from FlightAware's perspective due to the high level of interest and potential impact on the industry."

FlightAware's Daniel Baker, their Founder & CEO, adds that, "In August and September of 2010, FlightPrep repeatedly contacted FlightAware in order to discuss its newly issued patent. Because our expertise is in software innovation rather than patent litigation, we referred the matter to our patent attorney.

He investigated the matter in depth, and provided our response to FlightPrep informing them that FlightAware did not infringe their patent. We have received no further communication from FlightPrep."

FlightAware notes that, "FlightPrep's patent does not broadly cover all forms of flight planning using the Internet. Indeed the Patent Office Examiner considered prior art that showed flight planning using the Internet, both with and without waypoints.

The scope of FlightPrep's patent claims is thus narrower, and requires details that FlightAware does not do. We remain focused and committed to developing & providing the best aviation software that we can. We encourage everyone, including FlightPrep, to do the same. The recent patent news will not affect our innovation or the services that we provide." 



More News

ANN's Daily Aero-Term (05.25.22): Minimum Vectoring Altitude (MVA)

Minimum Vectoring Altitude (MVA) The lowest MSL altitude at which an IFR aircraft will be vectored by a radar controller, except as otherwise authorized for radar approaches, depar>[...]

ANN FAQ: How Do I Become A News Spy?

We're Everywhere... Thanks To You! Even with the vast resources and incredibly far-reaching scope of the Aero-News Network, every now and then a story that should be reported on sl>[...]

Airborne 05.25.22: Seaplane v Obnoxious HOA, Global 8000, Sonaca Halts

Also: Gogo Goes Global, NAA Honors Skydivers, Dassault Falcon 6x FlightSim, Pilotless Airplane--Ooopps A seaplane owner has incurred the wrath of a local homeowner’s associat>[...]

Airborne 05.23.22: STOL Tragedy, GAMA Report 1Q/22, ALPA v Age Increases

Also: Young Eagles 30th Anniversary, Pilot Recovering From Caravan Incident, Frontier And Spirit, Hartzell Engine Seminars The GA STOL competition phenomena has become all the rage>[...]

Aero-News: Quote of the Day (05.26.22)

"This quarter's report is unique in the fact that year-over-year forward-fit sales jumped 34.6%, which coincides with increased airplane deliveries, and we simultaneously saw year->[...]

blog comments powered by Disqus





© 2007 - 2022 Web Development & Design by Pauli Systems, LC