NTSB: Biplane May Have Been Overweight, Out-Of-CG At Time Of Accident | Aero-News Network
Aero-News Network
RSS icon RSS feed
podcast icon MP3 podcast
Subscribe Aero-News e-mail Newsletter Subscribe

Airborne Unlimited -- Most Recent Daily Episodes

Episode Date



Airborne-Wednesday Airborne-Thursday


Airborne On YouTube




Airborne Special Edition-01.20.22

Airborne Special Edition-01.21.22

ANN LIVE Coverage of AEA 2021 Is Archived at www.airborne-live.net

Fri, Jan 06, 2006

NTSB: Biplane May Have Been Overweight, Out-Of-CG At Time Of Accident

Witnesses Say Pilots Were Performing Aerobatics

A Christen Eagle II that went down last year in Iowa may have been overweight and at the limit of its CG envelope for aerobatic flight, according to the NTSB Factual report issued on the accident this week.

As was reported in Aero-News, the two men onboard the small biplane died when the aircraft went down southwest of Iowa City on March 27. Witnesses at the scene told authorities the pilot had been performing aerobatic maneuvers, including flips and barrel rolls, prior to the accident.

The NTSB stated the aircraft's designer specifies a published rearward CG limit for flight within the acrobatic category of 99.60 inches, at a maximum gross weight of 1,520 pounds; and 100.40 at a weight of 1,450 pounds.

Investigators studied three scenarios with differing amounts of fuel onboard, according to the report, and found the aircraft may have been as much as 97 lbs overweight when the accident occurred, depending on fuel load. In both scenarios, the CG may have been anywhere from .2 to .3 inches outside the aft limit for aerobatic flight.

With 1/4 tank of fuel onboard, the aircraft would have been barely within its gross weight restriction (by only nine pounds) -- but the CG would have been .3 outside the envelope for the Christen Eagle II.

The findings are significant, as witnesses reported the aircraft entered a flat spin prior to impacting the ground. The reported gross weight and center-of-gravity conditions would have made it very difficult to exit such a maneuver, according to the NTSB.

The Christen Eagle Airplane Flight Manual is also very empathic on the subject.

"Any particular Christen Eagle II aircraft will recover from any spin type using standard recovery techniques ONLY IF THE AIRCRAFT IS PROPERLY BALANCED," it states. "The CG of the aircraft must be within design limits to ensure safe spin recovery. Any aircraft can be dangerously loaded (CG beyond design limits) making spin recovery extremely difficult or impossible. Weight and balance considerations must be taken seriously and pilots must be absolutely certain that the flight CG of their aircraft is within design limits."

And while it's not evident if it would have made a difference, the two victims -- David Culbertson and Steven Redman -- also were not wearing parachutes. FAR 91.307 requires parachutes to be worn anytime the pilot:

  1. Banks the aircraft more than 60 degrees relative to the horizon; or
  2. Pitches the nose up-or-down at an attitude of 30 degrees or more relative to the horizon.

NTSB investigators stressed the report does not specify a cause of the accident, adding the Probable Cause report may not be issued until later in the year.

FMI: Read The Factual Report


More News

ANN's Daily Aero-Term (01.22.22): Ground Controlled Approach

Ground Controlled Approach A radar approach system operated from the ground by air traffic control personnel transmitting instructions to the pilot by radio. The approach may be co>[...]

Aero-News: Quote of the Day (01.22.22)

“Only 5% of commercial pilots and 15% of computer scientists are women. In both areas – aviation and STEM – the gender gap is huge. But during my journey I met ma>[...]

ANN's Daily Aero-Linx (01.22.22)

Aero Linx: Venice Aviation Society Welcome to the Venice Aviation Society. VASI is the voice of Venice General Aviation. VASI is a non-profit organization dedicated to supporting b>[...]

Airborne-Unmanned 01.19.21: Zeva Zero Flies, UAS Taxi Outlook, Censys

Also: Masten Expands, Sonex Aerospace Sold, Collier Nominations, SuperBowl TFR Zeva has completed the first untethered flight test for its Zero flying wing airframe, where the airc>[...]

ANN's Daily Aero-Linx (01.23.22)

Aero Linx: Aviation Suppliers Association (ASA) Established February 25, 1993, the Aviation Suppliers Association (ASA), based in Washington, D.C., is a not-for-profit association,>[...]

blog comments powered by Disqus





© 2007 - 2022 Web Development & Design by Pauli Systems, LC