Supreme Court Hears Air Wisconsin Pilot's Case | Aero-News Network
Aero-News Network
RSS icon RSS feed
podcast icon MP3 podcast
Subscribe Aero-News e-mail Newsletter Subscribe

Airborne Unlimited -- Most Recent Daily Episodes

Episode Date

Airborne-Monday

Airborne-Tuesday

Airborne-Wednesday Airborne-Thursday

Airborne-Friday

Airborne On YouTube

Airborne-Unlimited-05.13.24

Airborne-NextGen-05.07.24

Airborne-Unlimited-05.08.24 Airborne-FlightTraining-05.09.24

Airborne-Unlimited-05.10.24

Thu, Dec 12, 2013

Supreme Court Hears Air Wisconsin Pilot's Case

Questions Language Used To Describe Pilot's Mood After Failing Exams

The Supreme Court of the United States (SCOTUS) heard oral arguments on Monday in a case involving an Air Wisconsin pilot who had sued the airline and won a $1.4 million judgment in the case.

The central issue was whether the airline used language that could be misinterpreted when it reported to TSA that pilot William Hoeper was "mentally unstable" after failing a series of test needed to qualify in a new type of aircraft. Hoeper left the fourth test abruptly, cursing and shouting, according to a report in the New York Times.

It was also reported to TSA that as a flight deck officer, Hoeper might be armed on the plane.

Justice Sonia Sotomayor said the description provided to TSA was too strong. "Why choose the words ‘mentally unstable’? Isn’t it with an intent to connote something more than the facts?” A lawyer for the airline countered that federal law encourages quick, if informal, reports of "suspicious activities" without having to be concerned about "hairsplitting distinctions" later.

The Colorado Supreme Court determined that Mr. Hoeper's actions may have warranted a call to TSA, but writing for that court's majority, Chief Justice Nancy Rice said the report to TSA “overstated those events to such a degree that they were made with reckless disregard of their truth or falsity.”

Justice Antonin Scalia said that the there is a difference between someone being mentally unstable and simply losing his or her temper. But he added that such a statement is only materially false if authorities would have reacted differently after being told a person is angry rather than being told they are "mentally unstable."

The justices also considered the effects of the TSA's "if you see something, say something" policy of quickly reporting "suspicious" activity.

A lawyer for Mr. Hoeper said SCOTUS should use a 1991 decision in a case involving a profile written for a magazine that was eventually deemed slanderous as precedent to find for his client. But Justice Anthony Kennedy, who wrote that opinion for the court, said there is a difference between a journalist who has months to write a story with editors and proofreaders and "the baggage handler who has only 10 minutes to decide what he’s going to say.”

FMI: www.supremecourt.gov/Search.aspx?FileName=/docketfiles/12-315.htm

Advertisement

More News

Sierra Space Repositions Dream Chaser for First Mission

With Testing Soon Complete, Launch Preparations Begin in Earnest Sierra Space's Dream Chaser has been put through the wringer at NASA's Glenn Armstrong Test Facility in Ohio, but w>[...]

ANN's Daily Aero-Term (05.10.24): Takeoff Roll

Takeoff Roll The process whereby an aircraft is aligned with the runway centerline and the aircraft is moving with the intent to take off. For helicopters, this pertains to the act>[...]

Aero-News: Quote of the Day (05.10.24)

“We’re proud of the hard work that went into receiving this validation, and it will be a welcome relief to our customers in the European Union. We couldn’t be mor>[...]

Aero-News: Quote of the Day (05.11.24)

"Aircraft Spruce is pleased to announce the acquisition of the parts distribution operations of Wag-Aero. Wag-Aero was founded in the 1960’s by Dick and Bobbie Wagner in the >[...]

ANN's Daily Aero-Term (05.11.24): IDENT Feature

IDENT Feature The special feature in the Air Traffic Control Radar Beacon System (ATCRBS) equipment. It is used to immediately distinguish one displayed beacon target from other be>[...]

blog comments powered by Disqus



Advertisement

Advertisement

Podcasts

Advertisement

© 2007 - 2024 Web Development & Design by Pauli Systems, LC