California Court Upholds Local No-Banner Law | Aero-News Network
Aero-News Network
RSS icon RSS feed
podcast icon MP3 podcast
Subscribe Aero-News e-mail Newsletter Subscribe

Airborne Unlimited -- Recent Daily Episodes

Episode Date

Airborne Unlimited-
Monday

Airborne-Unmanned w/AUVSI-
Tuesday

Airborne Unlimited-
Wednesday

AMA Drone Report-
Thursday

Airborne Unlimited-
Friday

Airborne On ANN

Airborne Unlimited-01.14.19

Airborne Unmanned-01.15.19

Airborne Unlimited-01.16.19

AMA Drone Report-01.17.19

Airborne Unlimited-01.18.19

Airborne-YouTube

Airborne Unlimited-01.14.19

Airborne Unmanned-01.15.19

Airborne Unlimited-01.16.19

AMA Drone Report-01.17.19

Airborne Unlimited-01.18.19

Mon, Jan 14, 2002

California Court Upholds Local No-Banner Law

Honolulu Aerial Ad Ban Flies on Appeal

In October of 1998, US District Judge Helen Gillmor denied the right of SkySign International to challenge a Honolulu (HI) ordinance banning helicopter banner-towing. That denial was upheld last week, by the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals.

In the 1998 ruling, Gillmor said the city had, "an overwhelming aesthetic interest" in the ban, because Hawaii's tourism industry depends so much on the "beauty of the islands."

SkySign, for its part, noted that the airspace wasn't regulated by cities. In the October 1997 suit, SkySign pointed out that the FAA, which, until that time, was in charge of such things, had properly permitted the business to tow banners in US airspace. The Honolulu City Council decided to overrule the FAA, and SkySign was left to defend its right to make a living. That right was denied, after a year, by Judge Helen; her ruling was affirmed by the appeals court.

The ruling was possible because the Court considered SkySign's emphasis to be "advertising," rather than "flying," a precedent that could open a huge can of worms, and will, we predict, eviscerate the FAA's authority over the airspace. The Court acknowledged that SkySign was somehow connected to flying, it ruled, "...however, advertising is an area traditionally subject to regulation under the states' police power, and we therefore presume that federal law does not displace Honolulu's regulatory authority over advertising absent a clear statement of the federal intent to do so." [By that reasoning, we suppose the cities could  authorize anyone's flying over a populated area, if the city were the one which was advertising. Since the pilot wouldn't be involved in "aviation," but rather in "advertising," why should the FAA have anything to say about it? --ed]

The City Council said it had been responding to citizens' complaints about the 8' x36' electric-lighted sign that SkySign typically displayed off Oahu's beaches.

FMI: http://www.co.honolulu.hi.us/mayor/goals.htm, www.faa.gov 

Advertisement

More News

Airborne 01.16.19: ATC Gets Pizza, SpaceX LayOffs, AirVenture '19 AirShow

Also: Plane-Power Six-Phase A/C Alternators, NATCA Sues, AirFlair Winner, Lion Air Flight 610 CVR Canadian air traffic controllers are doing what they can to help out their U.S. co>[...]

Airborne 01.16.19: ATC Gets Pizza, SpaceX LayOffs, AirVenture '19 AirShow

Also: Plane-Power Six-Phase A/C Alternators, NATCA Sues, AirFlair Winner, Lion Air Flight 610 CVR Canadian air traffic controllers are doing what they can to help out their U.S. co>[...]

Garmin TeamX Introduces The GTR 200B Comm Radio

Designed For Experimental And Amateur-Built Aircraft, Unit Includes Bluetooth Intercom Garmin has introduced the GTR 200B, a comm radio and Bluetooth-enabled intercom designed spec>[...]

Airborne 01.14.19: Air Race Classic, Student In Distress, AirCam Bahamas

Also: AvGroups Urge End To Shutdown, USAF Accepts KC-46A, Hubble Images, New Airport for Knoxville? Registration is open for the 43rd Air Race Classic (ARC), the annual all-women c>[...]

AAR Forms New Partnership With Rock Valley College In Illinois

Will Enhance Aviation Maintenance Instruction And Students' Career Prospects Aviation services provider AAR and Rock Valley College in Rockford, IL have announced expansion of thei>[...]

blog comments powered by Disqus



Advertisement

Advertisement

Podcasts

Advertisement

© 2007 - 2019 Web Development & Design by Pauli Systems, LC