Pirker Responds To FAA Appeal Through Legal Brief | Aero-News Network
Aero-News Network
RSS icon RSS feed
podcast icon MP3 podcast
Subscribe Aero-News e-mail Newsletter Subscribe

Airborne Unlimited -- Most Recent Daily Episodes

Episode Date

Airborne-Monday

Airborne-Tuesday

Airborne-Wednesday Airborne-Thursday

Airborne-Friday

Airborne On YouTube

Airborne-Unlimited-07.21.25

Airborne-Unlimited-07.22.25

AirborneUnlimited-07.23.25

Airborne-Unlimited-07.24.25

AirborneUnlimited-07.25.25

Thu, May 15, 2014

Pirker Responds To FAA Appeal Through Legal Brief

Calls FAA Action 'Unprecedented Regulation-By-Policy'

Attorneys for Raphael Pirker have filed a legal brief in response to the FAA's appeal of an NTSB Administrative Law Judge's decision to dismiss a $10,000 fine against the young UAV operator.

The brief calls the FAA's action against Pirker, and by extension its commercial ban on UAV use, "unprecedented regulation-by-policy of a previously unregulated device so as to impose an unprecedented (and unenforceable) ban on "business" use of that technology.

"Out of the likely one billion model aircraft operations in United States history, why did the FAA pursue enforcement only against this one, involving a five-pound styrofoam model which caused no injury or property damage? Why has the FAA bent over backwards to call into question the very meaning of an obvious term it has freely used for decades, "model aircraft"? Because the alleged purpose of Mr. Pirker's model aircraft operation was commercial," the brief states.

"It is undisputed that the FAA has never expressly regulated model aircraft or unmanned aircraft systems. In 1981, the agency confirmed this lack of model aircraft regulation by issuing Advisory Circular AC 91-57, requesting only "voluntary compliance" with safety standards "for model aircraft operators." These standards, such as a request that models be flown below 400 feet AGL, do not specifically align with any actual federal aviation regulations, such as altitude restrictions or airspace classifications," the brief continues. "AC 91-57 makes no distinction between model aircraft flown for commercial purposes and those flown for recreation. Nor does it distinguish between public and civil operators. It applies to any "model aircraft operators." Nowhere does the FAA indicate the possibility of an aviation penalty. Indeed, that notion is "incompatible" with standards that are "voluntary.""

Pirker's attorneys say that the absence of any enforceable regulation concerning model aircraft operation is confirmed by "the complete historical absence of FAA (or NTSB) involvement in those very rare instances where model aircraft caused property damage, injury, or even death.

"For example, neither the FAA nor NTSB investigated when a girl in a park was injured by a model helicopter near McDill Air Force base, nor did they investigate the fatal accident involving a large-scale model helicopter in Brooklyn last September. These incidents were handled by local police.

"Notably, model aircraft have an extraordinary safety record, and such incidents remain extremely rare," the brief states.

What is clear is that neither side is going to give up this fight easily. Stay tuned ...

FMI: Legal Brief

Advertisement

More News

ANN/Oshkosh Sponsor, Gleim Aviation, Is Ready To Teach You A Thing Or Two...

Come To Oshkosh, Get Educated by Gleim At Booth #1103-1105 Gleim Aviation, industry leader in aviation training materials, was founded in 1980 for one reason: Dr. Irvin N. Gleim lo>[...]

ANN Thanks Our Speedy Sponsor... Blackshape!!!

Check out Blackshape in Oshkosh Display #190 Situated in the Apulian Aerospace district in Monopoli, Italy, Blackshape embodies the epitome of Italian craftsmanship, style, and qua>[...]

Alpha Systems AOA Guides ANN Oshkosh Coverage

A Powerhouse In Aviation Safety Technology, Visit Alpha Systems AOA at Osh Display#3124-3125 Alpha systems AOA has been developing and integrating Angle of Attack systems for the l>[...]

Airborne-Flight Training 07.17.25: Dual Ignition C172, CFI-ATP Course, FAA Boss

Also: Adventure Pilot iFly EFB X7, Endorsements Made Easy, H55 B23 Energic, Kings & USAF Cessna’s long-running Skyhawk now features a solid-state dual electronic ignition>[...]

Airborne 07.24.25: Spirit SE-1!, H55 eFlyer, King Schools

Also: Centauri Aircraft Valkyrie, Meet the Admin, Night Airshow, Pelton Intv'w When we laid eyes on this critter, we fell in love… and then we learned the amazing story of t>[...]

blog comments powered by Disqus



Advertisement

Advertisement

Podcasts

Advertisement

© 2007 - 2025 Web Development & Design by Pauli Systems, LC