Tue, Apr 15, 2014
Says Judge 'Erred' In Making Assumptions About The UAV, Interpretation Of FARs
The FAA has appealed an NTSB judges' ruling that a UAV flown by a private citizen in the vicinity of the University of Virginia is not subject to FARs, and the pilot of the UAV should not have to pay the agency's $10,000 fine.
Forbes reports that the FAA has filed a brief with the NTSB stating that the judge "erred" when he determined that the UAV, flown by Raphael Pirker, was not an "aircraft" under FAR definitions. They also hold that the judge incorrectly determined that the UAVs operation is not covered under current regulations.
Forbes' contributor John Goglia, who served 10 years on the NTSB, says that it is not logical for the FAA to suddenly determine that small UAVs no longer fall under the category of "model aircraft," which they have been considered for years. He also holds that the agency's distinction between commercial and non-commercial uses does not make sense if the issue is whether the UAV is an aircraft at all.
Goglia consulted with an attorney, who told him that the FAA definitely has the regulatory authority to control commercial uses of UAVs "of any size," but Congress has denied the FAA the authority to regulate model aircraft flown for hobby or recreational purposes. But, attorney Loretta Alkalay, who worked for the FAA before becoming an adjunct professor at the Vaughn College of Aeronautics, said that she does not think the FAA has properly crafted regulations for that purpose, and that it has created "its own legal confusion" in how it distinguishes between model aircraft and other aircraft.
The appeal will be heard by members of the NTSB who are responsible for reviewing appeals of FAA cases.
More News
Maximum Authorized Altitude A published altitude representing the maximum usable altitude or flight level for an airspace structure or route segment. It is the highest altitude on >[...]
Aero Linx: Soaring Safety Foundation (SSF) The Soaring Safety Foundation (SSF) is the Training and Safety arm of the Soaring Society of America (SSA). Our mission is to provide ins>[...]
From 2013 (YouTube Version): Dracula Lives On Through Kyle Franklin... and We're NOT Scared! ANN CEO and Editor-in-Chief, Jim Campbell speaks with Aerobatic and airshow master, Kyl>[...]
“For Montaer Aircraft it is a very prudent move to incorporate such reliable institution as Ocala Aviation, with the background of decades in training experience and aviation>[...]
Also: ForeFlight Upgrades, Cicare USA, Vittorazi Engines, EarthX We have a number of late-breaking news highlights from the 2024 Innovation Preview... which was PACKED with real ne>[...]